AI-Powered ERP and the Modern Manufacturing CFO

In part two of this interview on AI, ERP, and the Modern Manufacturing CFO, Jim Gross, Client Account Manager for NexTec’s Acumatica Cloud ERP customers, shares insights into how CFOs can make AI-powered ERP work to improve productivity, efficiency, and forecasting. Jim shares practical guidance on building trust in AI, preparing your data, implementing successfully, and proving ROI. Read part one for Jim’s perspectives on how AI is fundamentally changing the manufacturing finance function. 

What do you hear from clients in the mid-market around auditability, security, and governance around AI? Are they concerned?  

I’ll share a quick tidbit. A client called me a couple of months ago and said, “I need AI.” I said, “What do you need AI for?” He said, “Because Oscar in the warehouse isn’t doing his job right.” There’s still some lack of understanding about what AI really means in a modern ERP system. It’s not going to fix your personnel issues. 

What we can do is introduce AI slowly, in a way that makes sense to them. I think everybody’s familiar with Siri or Alexa at home now; you’re asking your phone questions. That just needs to happen in your day-to-day ERP system. A lot of times we tell customers to start small. “Let’s just close your books faster. How do we do that? Let’s start changing the way you do your reconciliations through your general ledger. Let’s set up some automated workflows.” That’s where you’ll start to see improvements, and that’s where you start building trust in AI.

“I think everybody’s familiar with Siri or Alexa at home now; you’re asking your phone questions. That just needs to happen in your day-to-day ERP system.”

Jim Gross, Customer Account Manager, NexTec Group 

The biggest request we get from any client post-go-live, three or six months later, is “I need to see dashboards.” With modern ERP systems offering unlimited users in any capacity, instead of getting a request from an executive to build a report or pull sales data, now you give them a dashboard and let them log in. 

For a small or mid-sized manufacturer whose finance team is still mired in spreadsheets and time-consuming manual reconciliations, what’s the first, most practical step you’d recommend they take when adopting AI-powered ERP? 

I’d say, let us build some workflows in the system. Let us build a couple of dashboards. When you see the data and can drill into it, back to the source documents and source transactions, that’s where you gain trust. 

I’m going to date myself here, but I came out of a DOS-based system, and some guy called me and said, “I’m with a company called Microsoft, and I want to show you all these changes.” Let me tell you, it took me a year to realize that was the future. But once I bought into it, it changed my entire world. It’s the same with AI and modern AI-powered ERP systems. You just have to get over that trust factor and say, “You know what? Let me see what the system can do.” 

What we try to do is paint some scenarios for them. Tell us your biggest struggle when you pull data together into an Excel file. What’s your biggest hurdle with trusting the data you’re pulling into that spreadsheet? Once we hear that, we do a use-case scenario showing how the system can pull that data for them, and that’s where we start building trust. Not everybody is going to jump on board immediately; we realize that. Some clients are old-school, and they’ll stay old-school. But the newer people coming in are being challenged by their owners and executives to deliver better reporting across the system.

This is a good segue to change management: How do you build trust with both the stakeholders and the end users? 

One of the things I always did as a project manager when I came on-site for discovery sessions with a client was to bring in Sally from AP and Johnny from the warehouse. We wanted to hear from the people who use the system the most, the ones doing the day-to-day processing. If we could get them on board and show them how ERP benefits them, makes their jobs easier, and gives them better reporting tools, then everything flows up. When they’re giving better analysis and better data to the executives, the executives have no choice but to say, “Let’s see what we can do throughout the entire system.” 

It’s about getting the entire company on board. Here’s a silly example: a truck comes in the door, somebody in the warehouse gets a packing slip, signs it, puts it in their back pocket, takes it home, washes it with their jeans, and it never gets to accounting. Now you’ve got real-time scanning. As products come off that truck and get scanned, accounting is updated that very second. Those are the changes we try to show them. The automation alone will change everything about your system. 

None of these new AI-powered ERP capabilities work without clean, high-quality data underneath it. What does getting your data into shape to use AI look like in a manufacturing environment, and how big a lift is that for a team? 

That’s the part that won’t change. It hasn’t changed from 20 or 30 years ago to today. You still have to go in and analyze the data. AI will give you the data. It will give you anomaly detection and predictive analysis. But you still have to go in and find out how it happened. Did it come from a supplier? Did it come from my sales team entering the wrong sales price or giving the wrong discount? You want to own that data, and you have to drill into it to find out what caused the problem, how to fix it, and how to put a new SOP in place so it doesn’t happen again. 

A lot of times when you move to a new ERP system, the biggest challenge is giving certain people more access in the system than they need. For example, a client called me two weeks ago and said, “My sales price tables keep changing. How does that happen?” We drilled down and found that somebody in customer service had the ability to change the sales price table. They should never have had that. It’s about things like role-based security, making sure certain people can see data but can’t change it. 

You still have to own the data. But what you can do more easily today is see where it happened, why it happened, who caused it, and then how to make a change so it doesn’t happen again. 

Is that something that would typically be done with a VAR like NexTec, or are there things a company looking to implement AI can do to prepare its data ahead of time? 

A lot of times clients will come to us, either on a cadence call or by reaching out to someone on our team, and say, “We don’t know what happened. We just know this happened. Help us dive into this.” 

That’s where our expertise comes into play: going in and showing them, with the idea that now that we’ve shown you how this happened in a sales order, production order, or whatever it might be, you can use that same logic for any part of your system.  

We’re always happy to help and always there to show them, but the idea is to make them as self-sufficient as possible. That way, going forward, they can identify these areas themselves and may simply come back to us and say, “We need tighter security. We need to lock down security at certain levels so these changes can’t be made by just anybody on the team.” We’re always here. We’ll certainly offer advice and show them how in the system. But at the end of the day, we want them to be self-sufficient. 

With so many ERP vendors claiming AI capabilities, what should a CFO look for in an AI-powered ERP solution, and how can they navigate the AI marketing hype?

Look, there are so many AI tools available to you, but what you really want to look at is what’s best for your company. What’s the best ERP system for your business? That’s where you break it down module by module. Some clients say, “I need a process manufacturing system,” or “I need a discrete manufacturing system.” Our job, if you will, is to make sure we’re filling all the gaps they need filled. 

That’s why it’s so important in the RFP process to understand the must-haves. What do you absolutely want to change, and what do you have now? The other thing is uncovering things the client might not even be thinking about. It’s important for us to do our job up front and explain what the system can and can’t do. The last thing we want to hear from anybody is, “I want my brand-new system to look exactly like my one from 25 years ago.” 

What does a realistic rollout timeline look like, and where do implementations typically stall? 

If we’re talking about a manufacturing implementation, we typically look at six to nine months for a full implementation. Where we can do our best job is stating up front that we need a dedicated project team lead on the client side. We need somebody who can focus 40 hours a week. If they don’t have that person on staff, we suggest they bring in a project manager to manage the project all the way through, because that person is the key to making sure everything we need from the client gets to us in a timely fashion. 

We hold weekly meetings to make sure we understand what was scheduled last week, what was completed, and what wasn’t. When we send out spreadsheets for data migration, we make sure they’re cleaned up and handed back to us. So, it really takes effort from the client to say, “We own this system.” The biggest problem we’ve seen in failed implementations is that the client doesn’t recognize that they own their own system. They expect someone like us to come in and just build it out the way we would, based on best practices. Those are failed implementations.  

It should be a 60/40 or 70/30 split, where the client owns the majority of it. At the end of the day, they’re the ones who’ll be entering data on go-live day one. We need to make sure they’re comfortable in their system, understand it, and own it. 

How does a mid-market manufacturer build the ROI case for this investment, and what’s a realistic payback timeline? 

This is where a conversation with NexTec will help, because we’ll assist you in building that business case. We need to understand what your team wants to focus on most. If you’re telling us you’re losing profit margin on 50% of your orders, let’s drill down and find out why. It could be that you have suppliers who can charge whatever they want based on today’s market, whereas locking in contracts with certain suppliers for a year is the kind of thing we used to do. So, we can help you build that business case to present to your team. 

A lot of times, we ask to be included in those meetings. We want to know what your executives are looking for, because that’s where the investment comes from. Executives aren’t going to be in the system day to day, but they’re the ones who want to see the results. If we don’t get their buy-in and understand what they’re looking for, that’s often where things get missed. We want to hear from them, help build that business case, and make sure they’re getting the data they need. 

For a mid-market manufacturer, an ERP is a significant technology investment. What do you tell them about realistic expectations for payback? 

Normally, what we say is that the system you have on go-live day one is not the system you’ll have six months later, because at first, you’re just trying to make sure you can do your day-to-day job. Unless serious initiatives are presented to us that must be part of a day-one go-live, most of our clients are just happy to go live and then start learning more about the system. 

Where we really see the cost savings is over the next six months to a year, when they start taking advantage of more features, the automation, AI predictability, and things like that. We truly expect the ROI to be a one to three-year journey, depending on how many phases the project has. But the idea is that you’re no longer looking back historically; you’re doing everything going forward. That’s really the big sell: you’re now going to have a system that looks forward, as opposed to always looking behind. 

What new skills does a finance team need to work effectively with AI? 

Really, it’s buying into the system and understanding more about it. Again, the biggest challenge we have is that we come into a company and ask, “When’s the last time you had any training on your system?” and they say, “I started here 20 years ago and haven’t had training since.” 

So, it’s continuous training. Continuous improvement. One great thing about our Acumatica ERP system is that there’s a learning tool included with your subscription, and you can get certified if you need to. You can stay fresh on all the changes that come out in the two major upgrades each year. 

Our big push is: Don’t stay stagnant. There’s an old joke: “I’ve been practicing medicine for 45 years.” No, you’ve been practicing the same medicine for 45 years. You have to grow with the system. You have to take ownership of the fact that things are changing in your system and stay up to date on them. You can do that on your own, through your own learning path, or with the help of your VAR. But the most important thing is staying current in a modern ERP system. 

How can an experienced ERP consultant like NexTec help guide clients toward effective and responsible use of AI within their organizations? 

There’s no substitute for real-life experience. I was a CFO and controller of companies, so when I became a project manager, I brought my real-life experience with me. A lot of the issues I had with an outdated ERP system were my frustration points, and I wanted to make sure that in Acumatica, a modern ERP system, we could solve them. We were able to show clients the value by saying, “This is what I used to have to do in my old ERP system. This is what I can do in this new ERP system.” 

Our team is comprehensive and coast-to-coast. We have a development team, an upgrade team, and a support team. When you sign on with NexTec, you’re not just signing on with an implementation team; you’re signing on with all the resources we have available. 

Let’s face it, every ERP system is going to lack some functionality. It just will. It can’t have everything. When a customer or company needs some additional feature, the first thing we do is find out whether we can do it without customization. We don’t want to customize the system just for the sake of it. That’s where the Acumatica Marketplace comes in. There might be a third-party vendor with a solution we can bolt onto the system to bring in that functionality. We’re always looking for the best way to integrate with your system, as opposed to customizing it and making upgrades less desirable. 

If you could give one piece of advice to a CFO just beginning to explore AI capabilities in their ERP, what would it be? 

Listen to your team about what they’re looking for. Also understand who you have on your team and their abilities. You can’t expect everybody in the organization to jump into AI and understand it right away. 

I would take it a piece at a time. Focus on one specific area of the company, or one specific area of the ERP system, that you’d love to see AI solve for you. Get with NexTec and say, “We want to look into why our gross margin percentage fluctuated so much over the last six months.” Once you focus on one area, see what AI can do for you, and see the results, that’s where you gain confidence. Take a slower approach. If this is brand new to you, take a slower approach. Let the AI-powered ERP system show you what it can do, and then you can move forward with other areas of the system. 

So many times, our clients are afraid to step out of their comfort zone. And again, some of them figure, “If AI can do it, I’m going to lose my job.” Give them the comfort of showing them they’re now a better resource because of these new advances. And you’ll be a better CFO for bringing this to the company’s attention and showing them that the system they just invested heavily in is now going to do the work for them. 

JIm Gross Headshot

Jim Gross is a Client Account Manager in NexTec’s Acumatica ERP consulting practice, working with clients to help them implement and optimize their core financial systems and processes to support sustainable growth. Jim has been working with Microsoft Dynamics SL since 1989 and Acumatica since 2017.

Before he began providing management and financial systems consulting, Jim spent 9 years in corporate management, working as a Controller in the service industry and as CFO at a fast-growing manufacturing firm, where he led the selection and implementation of an ERP system to handle the growth of their business and manage their vast product inventory.

With nearly four decades of experience with financial and ERP systems, he brings a wealth of real-world expertise to every Acumatica implementation. Outside of work, Jim loves golfing, hiking, taking beach vacations, and spending time with his wife Missy and their two kids and four grandkids. He also travels extensively doing mission work in the US and abroad.